TORNADO WATCH IS IN EFFECT UNTIL 9:00 PM FOR ALL OF TEXOMA...
Horse racing community mourns tragedy at Kentucky Derby Save Email Print
Posted: 5:32 PM May 8, 2008
Last Updated: 10:35 PM May 8, 2008
Reporter: Daniel Gotera
Email Address: daniel.gotera@kxii.com


A | A | A

COOKE COUNTY, Tex. -- The horse racing community continues to mourn the loss of Eight Belles, the filly euthanized on Saturday after finishing the Kentucky Derby. In the wake of the tragic accident, many people are asking why she had to be put down. Local horse enthusiasts say sometimes these tragedies just cannot be avoided. Daniel Gotera talked with them and explains why.

Animal rights activists like People For The Ethical Treatment Of Animals (PETA) have directed their anger over Eight Belles’ death at jockey Guillermo Saez, who they claim didn’t pull up eight belles earlier in the race, but those who know the sport and the animals say this was nobody's fault and just an unfortunate circumstance.

Former jockey Stephen Michael rode horses competitively from 1997 to 2004. He, like the rest of the country, was saddened at Eight Belles' death at Churchill Downs last weekend. But Michael says all the extra heat being put on Eight Belles' jockey is uncalled for, because all jockeys are trained to take the necessary steps during a race to keep the horse and other riders safe.

Officials at Babcock Ranch just south of Gainesville say most horses bred for speed are fragile, but no less fragile than any others. They see many horses euthanized every year due to injuries out on the pastures.

It just so happened that this time, it was in front of the whole world.

"It’s just something that happens. If she hadn’t had that happen, she would have gone down in the history books as one of the greatest mares of all time, and we would have seen a lot of her goals in the future," Jim Babcock at Babcock Ranch says.

Michael says while he was racing, he never rode a horse that was tired or had a prior condition. He says it's a shame this happened, especially since it's rare that a filly does so well in the Kentucky Derby.

Email  del.icio.us   Google   Yahoo  digg
More Stories
Original Oklahoma State Trooper honored

Gainesville looks forward to opening of new high school

High speed motorcycle chase ends near Callisburg

Gateway West addition plans approved in Denison

Fugitive search in Fannin Co.

Safe Family: National Bite Prevention Month

Copper theft near Whitesboro

Ardmore police investigating 6-month-old child’s death

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Burma Location: Shaved on May 12, 2008 at 03:49 PM
Yep, the owners killed her if they knew her bones were not developed to run that hard. Bless her heart, I wonder how long of time they were broken while racing? Horrible...it's all about greed and money.

Posted by: M Location: Durant on May 12, 2008 at 03:32 PM
To THOSE of you who really dont have a concept of the point I was trying to get across then I really feel sorry for you. I have a child and NO I would not put her down for breaking a leg or two. What I was trying to say is that horses get injured NO MATTER what they are doing. This is not any different, other than a sad incident and the trainers and vet did do the humane thing. Ok K and anonymous maybe you will understand this. Say you both broke your legs playing a sport that you loved, that would be considered a sad incident. Even if you were young then people would not be throwing a fit because they think you were too young to start playing sports. You would have your legs set and casted. It would be a sad thing indeed. You cant do that with horses. Their weight and structure is not capable of that. By the way, it was not a comparsion just TWO examples of God's creatures doing what they love. K no I do not gamble.

Posted by: horse on May 12, 2008 at 01:42 PM
Um hello people, more horses get injured in their own pasture behaving like a typical horse than in the sports world. However, all horse industries, especially cutting and reigning and racing should really look at the age of these horses and what they are putting them through at such a young age. Look at teh english world and you will see that the champions of the jumping/hunting world are 10 - 15 years old.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 10, 2008 at 09:12 AM
M, you are comparing a horse to a child what? As a child you take vitamins and drink milk for your bones, do not compare a horse to a kid

Posted by: Jennifer Location: Omaha NE on May 10, 2008 at 09:10 AM
I saw my very first horse race at an off track betting place here in Omaha on the day of the Kentucky derby. I did actively participate, for monetary gain in the race the ultimatly resulted in the death of Eight Belles. I carry the guilt with me now and probably always will, that I knowingly participated in a sport that was directly responsible for the death of this magnificent animal. At first I enjoyed the race, I had never seen a horse race before, and was not aware that there was an "accident" on the track. This was not shown on the simulcast at the track I was at. Eight Belles was a beautiful filly and I personally will never actively participate in this sport again. Any sport that is directly responsible for the death of an animal is highly questionable, and although I am told by friends who have worked in the sport that these animals are happy, I must question the relevance of the continuation of sport that uses animal's for the sole purpose of human enjoyment and monetary gain.

Posted by: Lacy Jo Location: Sherman Tx on May 9, 2008 at 10:58 PM
You people are so stuipd. The big deal is people like me love horses and if you knew anything about them then yall would really understaind WHATS THE BIG DEAL!!! When a horse has two broken ankiles , there not like human bones where you can just place them back together. Some people need to start doing their research. Thats the end of that.

Posted by: Amy Location: Sherman on May 9, 2008 at 10:17 PM
The jockey is a stud, I wished they would make him part of the sports team!!!!

Posted by: K Location: Sherman on May 9, 2008 at 09:45 PM
To M...If a child breaks it's leg...they don't get euthanized. So don't compare a kid to a horse. That's stupid of you to even think that. Eight Belles was killed by greed and gambling. Do you gamble on kid's sports???

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Sherman on May 9, 2008 at 02:28 PM
Why they got a cow on the Elmer's glue bottle if they use horses?

Posted by: Betty Location: Sherman on May 9, 2008 at 10:55 AM
It's just a horse. What's the big deal?

Posted by: M Location: Durant on May 9, 2008 at 10:19 AM
Nobody says anything when a child gets injuried play sports like basketball, softball, baseball or football while starting out at a young age when there bones are still developing. That is considered a sad incident and one of those things that just happens. Why is it any different with animals. The children that are playing sports are doing what they love, so are the horses that are athletes.

Posted by: M Location: Durant on May 9, 2008 at 10:16 AM
This was a sad incident that happened but all 20 horses in that race where related in some way to Native Dancer, as was Barbaro. Native Dancer genes do not have strong legs or ankles. Also if you have ever seen a race horse run up close, they just love to race. This could have happened anywhere to any horse whether they were just playing around in the pasture or on a pleasure ride. Ive had a horse that broke his leg just playing in the pasture and had to be put down. These horses are the best taken care of animals and are always given the upmost care and attention. Just because this incident happened on a race track and at one of the biggest races of the year is why its being publicized so much. There was nothing to do BUT put her down. She was in major pain and they did the humane thing for Eight Belles. She was young yes but so are all the other horses that get broke whether rodeo or just pleasure riding. As for the vet chalk it up to her herediaty.

Posted by: Tracy Location: Sherman on May 9, 2008 at 10:09 AM
I've worked w/ these people in the equine field. They are all about the money. If the animal can't compete, they will put them down in a heartbeat. I worked in an equine clinic where a horse was going lame and not able to perform to his fullest capability. The owner elected to put the horse down, even though there was a vet tech who wanted to take over care of the horse. These people are greedy and selfish and I hope there's an extra-hot spot in Hell just for them...

Posted by: Harry Location: Grayson on May 9, 2008 at 09:05 AM
Lets be clear about this. This mare was a two year old. Ask most any vet and they will tell you that a two year horses bones are so soft (still developing) and tender that any vigorous training should not be started until at least three years old. This horse was brought along much faster than she should have been and as a result there is a total loss due to a catastrophic injury. What caused this to happen? Greed, pure and simple. The owners wanted to start making money and took a chance on something not happening...and lost. Unfortunately the owners realized what could happen, Eight Belles did not.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 9, 2008 at 07:59 AM
Its all about the money...forget the horse.

Posted by: Re: Me on May 9, 2008 at 12:29 AM
The injury was severe--both of her front legs had broken near the knees. Treating a horse with one broken leg (like Barbaro) is difficult at best, but with two broken legs it's impossible. Euthanasia in this case was the only humane choice, and it was done quickly to spare her from suffering as much pain as possible. As for PETA trying to blame the jockey, I don't buy it; I watched the race and the replays several times...the horse was slowing down already, and showed no signs of problems before the injury occurred...there was no reason for the jockey to have acted any differently in this case than he would have with any other horse.

Posted by: don't kill animals Location: lettuce prey on May 8, 2008 at 10:27 PM
So sad. A beautiful animal who obviously put her whole heart into running...put down... because of human greed and gambling.

Posted by: Chuck Location: Sherman on May 8, 2008 at 09:25 PM
wow....this story was a stretch

Posted by: Horse Lover on May 8, 2008 at 09:23 PM
And PETA is full of it, by the way... I don't think they'll be happy until humans are wiped off the face of the earth and animals are left totally alone.

Posted by: Horse Lover on May 8, 2008 at 09:22 PM
They COULDN'T save her, she couldn't stand up as both her front ankles were broken! If she had just one broken ankle she could've stood on her other 3 legs to get into the equine ambulance... but who knows, maybe she would've ended up as anothre Barbaro, euthanized after months & months of painful treatment & rehabilitation.

Posted by: Me on May 8, 2008 at 06:40 PM
It is very sad and I too was wondering why they didn't do more to save her. However, if you think about it, she was really something and I would be willing to bet that in the future she would have brought in a lot of money in winnings so if she could have been saved then I bet they would have.

AP Video on KXII